Effects of Pitch and Rhythm Priming Tasks on Accuracy and Fluency During Sight-Reading

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of pitch and rhythm priming tasks on sight-reading accuracy and fluency. High school wind instrumentalists ( N = 182) were assigned to one of four experimental groups: pre-/posttest rhythm, pre-/posttest pitch, posttest-only rhythm, or posttest-only pitch. Participants sight-read selected stimulus exercises from the Watkins-Farnum Performance Scale and completed two priming treatments and a control condition as part of a repeated-measures design. A three-way repeated-measures MANOVA, with rhythm accuracy, pitch accuracy, and fluency accuracy as dependent measures, revealed a significant main effect due to priming condition. Rhythm accuracy scores were significantly lower after both perceptual and conceptual priming than after a control condition. No significant differences in pitch accuracy or fluency existed based on priming condition. No significant differences were found in rhythm, pitch, or fluency accuracy based on treatment condition (pitch or rhythm) or exposure condition (pre-/posttest or post only). Two-way repeated-measures MANOVAs revealed significant main effects based on time. Pitch accuracy and fluency each significantly improved between pre- and posttest and from the first to third study tasks. Results suggest that performing rhythm alone or pitch alone requires different cognitive processes than does performing both together.

Melody, not Beat Perception, Predicts Rhythmic Error Detection

“…Of course, scores on the melodic error detection test were predictive of scores on the rhythmic error detection test. This result is important because previous findings on sight-reading skill suggest a limited relationship between pitch and rhythm accuracy (Byo, 1992; Mishra, 2016; Russell, 2019). Age was a less important factor in predicting rhythm errors in the present study than it was for pitch errors in a previous study (Stambaugh & Nichols, 2020).…”

Piano education online: Challenges and solutions

“…The effect of physical parameters on the study of piano compositions was considered by scientists from the USA (Russell, 2019). The determining factors are pitch and rhythm, accuracy and fluency of sight reading, accuracy or smoothness of sound (Russell, 2019).…”