Effects of requested, forced and denied shift schedule change on work ability and health of nurses in Europe -Results from the European NEXT-Study

Abstract

BackgroundPrevious cross-sectional findings from the European Nurses Early Exit Study (NEXT) show that nurses who were dissatisfied with their work schedule tended to consider leaving the nursing profession. Mediating factors in this decision process may be caused by self-perceived poor work ability and/or health. The aim of this paper is to investigate changes in work ability and general health among nurses in relation to requested, forced and denied change of shift schedule.MethodsLongitudinal data from the NEXT Study was used. In total 11,102 nurses from Belgium, Germany, Finland, the Netherlands, Poland, Slovakia, France and Italy completed both the ‘basic questionnaire’ (t1) and the ’12 month follow-up questionnaire’ (t2). To examine the time-effect (repeated measures) and the group-effect of five defined groups of nurses on the Work Ability Index (WAI) and general health (SF36), an adjusted 2-way analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was performed.ResultsThe nurses who wanted to, but could not change their shifts during the 12 month follow-up had the lowest initial and follow-up scores for WAI (t1: 37.6, t2: 36.6, p <0.001), lowest general health (t1: 63.9, t2: 59.2, p <0.001) and showed the highest decrease in both outcomes. Shift pattern change in line with the nurses’ wishes was associated with improved work ability and to a lesser comparatively low extent with increased decline in health scores. A forced change of shift against the nurses’ will was significantly associated with a deteriorating work ability and health.ConclusionsThe findings would suggest that nurses’ desire to change their shift patterns may be an indicator for perceived low work ability and/or low health. The results also indicate that fulfilling nurses’ wishes with respect to their shift work pattern may improve their personal resources such as work ability and – to somewhat lesser extent – health. Disregarding nurses’ preferences, however, bears the risk for further resource deterioration. The findings imply that shift schedule organization may constitute a valuable preventive tool to promote nurses’ work ability and – to lesser extent – their perceived health, not least in aging nursing work forces.

Determinants of Grip Strength in Tunisian Nurses: A Bicentric Study

“…Moreover, in 996-nurse- study population, Fischer [ 35 ], found that the nursing occupation was associated with stressful working conditions and contributed to inadequate WAI. These results are consistent with those of the European NEXT study population suggesting that shift schedule organization in nurses may promote their workability [ 36 ].…”

Organization of Work Factors Associated with Work Ability among Aging Nurses

“…Without that flexibility, many would not still be at the bedside or would be at a different institution or within a different unit/specialty. Findings from the European Nurses Early Exit Study (NEXT) support what our participants described; valuing nurses' preferences for shift schedule is one way to potentially prevent nurses from leaving the profession early as well as promoting work ability (Galatsch, Li, Derycke, Müller, & Hasselhorn, 2013).…”

The Impact of Arts Activity on Nursing Staff Well-Being: An Intervention in the Workplace

“…The SF-36 [ 40 ] has been validated and used as a generic measure of health status in different target groups such as general population, clinical and medical staff [ 41 , 42 , 43 , 44 , 45 ]. SF-36 relates to an individual’s subjective general health over the previous month.…”