One
type of firefighting foam, referred to as aqueous film-forming
foams (AFFF), is known to contain per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances
(PFAS). The concerns raised with PFAS, and their potential environmental
and health impacts, have led to a surge in research on fluorine-free
alternatives both in the United States and globally. Particularly,
in January 2023, a new military specification (MIL-PRF-32725) for
fluorine-free foam was released in accordance with Congressional requirements
for the U.S. Department of Defense. This paper provides a critical
analysis of the present state of the various fluorine-free options
that have been developed to date. A nuanced perspective of the challenges
and opportunities of more sustainable replacements is explored by
examining the performance, cost, and regulatory considerations associated
with these fluorine-free alternatives. Ultimately, this evaluation
shows that the transition to fluorine-free replacements is likely
to be complex and multifaceted, requiring careful consideration of
the trade-offs involved. Yet, the ongoing work will provide valuable
insights for future research on alternatives to AFFF and enhancing
the safety and sustainability of fire suppression systems.