Effects of Soft Loans and Credit Guarantees on Performance of Supported Firms: Evidence from the Czech Public Programme START

Abstract

Abstract:The purpose of this article was to conduct an empirical evaluation of the Czech public programme START, which was funded from the European Regional Development Fund. The programme lasted from 2007-2011, and supported new entrepreneurs through the zero interest soft loans and credit guarantees. The counterfactual analysis (using three matching techniques: propensity score, nearest neighbour, and kernel) was conducted on the firm level and investigated the changes in financial performance (net profits, return on assets (ROA), return on equity (ROE), sales, assets turnover, and debt ratio) of the supported firms four years after the end of intervention. The obtained findings could not support the hypothesis assuming a positive impact of the programme on the firm's performance. On the contrary, supported companies reported on average lower sales and lower return on assets, when compared to the control group. The remaining variables could not prove any statistically significant impact of the programme. Indicators measuring firm's profitability (net profit, return on assets, and return on equity) suggested a negative influence of the programme and the variable representing debt ratio further indicated that firms that were supported by the programme reported on average higher debt ratio in comparison with the control group. Several policy implications are discussed in the study.

Public Support of Private R&D–Effects on Economic Sustainability

“…The aim of this paper is to address the effect of public R&D support of private companies on their economic sustainability. We use a combined approach to evaluate what effects public R&D support have on the private sector in the Czech Republic-a country where the microeconomic evaluation of public policies has not received much attention thus far [28]. First, we analyze if public R&D subsidies to private companies have had an effect on traditional R&D outcomes, which is innovation capacity as measured by patents.…”

Assessing the microeconomic effects of public subsidies on the performance of firms in the czech food processing industry: A counterfactual impact evaluation

“…Regardless of increasing emphasis on the counterfactual impact evaluation of public policies (e.g., Dvouletý, ; Dvouletý & Lukeš, ; Huergo & Moreno, ; Pellegrini & Muccigrosso, ; Porro & Salis, ), there are not many publications in outstanding agri‐food economics journals on this topic and, moreover, they are, for the most part, geared toward agriculture rather than toward the food industry (e.g., Anderson, Jensen, Nelgen, & Strutt, ; Esposti & Sotte, ; Läpple & Hennessy, ; Mendola, ; Petrick & Zier, ; Wang, ). In fact, many studies conducting impact evaluations have been published in conference proceedings or as working/seminar papers (e.g., Bartova & Hurnakova, ; Fan, ; Kirchweger & Kantelhardt, ; Ratinger, Medonos, & Hruška, ).…”

The Interaction of Borrower and Loan Characteristics in Predicting Risks of Subprime Automobile Loans

“…This cohort of borrowers is, to some extent, already rationed in the normal credit market and consequentially, finds it hard to secure loans in the subprime market due to bad credit history. They need special help from the government in the form of guarantees and subsidies if these individuals are to become entrepreneurs (Dvouletý 2017) for more discussion in this regard).…”