Injection of interstitial atoms by specially prepared surfaces submerged in liquid water near room temperature offers an attractive approach for post-synthesis defect manipulation and isotopic purification in device structures. However, this approach can be limited by trapping reactions that form small defect clusters. The compositions and dissociation barriers of such clusters remain mostly unknown. This communication seeks to address this gap by measuring the dissociation energies of oxygen interstitial traps in rutile TiO2 and wurtzite ZnO exposed to liquid water. Isotopic self-diffusion measurements using 18O, combined with progressive annealing protocols, suggest the traps are small interstitial clusters with dissociation energies ranging from 1.3 to 1.9 eV. These clusters may comprise a family incorporating various numbers, compositions, and configurations of O and H atoms; however, in TiO2, native interstitial clusters left over from initial synthesis may also play a role. Families of small clusters are probably common in semiconducting oxides and have several consequences for post-synthesis defect manipulation and purification of semiconductors using submerged surfaces.