Effects of water levels and water level regulation on the supply of suitable spawning habitat for eight fish guilds in the Bay of Quinte, Lake Ontario

Abstract

Lake Ontario water levels are regulated under the International Joint Commission's Order of Approval. We assessed the availability of spawning habitat for eight fish guilds (grouped by vegetation and spawning temperature preferences) that use nearshore habitat in the Bay of Quinte, Lake Ontario, under regulated and pre-project water level scenarios. Our model used habitat characteristics of depth, substrate, vegetation cover and temperature across 14,876 habitat units and guild-based habitat suitabilities to assess the weighted suitable area (WSA) available for spawning. During the modelled 1951–2000 period, regulated water levels were on average 0.25 m lower than pre-project levels and varied about half as much. Overall, the large and shallow upper bay within the Bay of Quinte benefited from pre-project flows whereas the smaller and deeper lower bay benefited from regulated flows. Higher variance in water levels increased highly suitable wetland area and higher mean water levels increased the availability of shallow flooded area in the upper and middle bays, where the bathymetry is gradually sloping. The number of days over which WSA was available was generally greater for high temperature guilds, and appeared to decrease when temperature mismatches occurred in a season. Results emphasize the complexity of the relationship between fish habitat supply and water level regime.

Comparison of Electrofishing Techniques and Effort Allocation across Diel Time Periods, Seasons, Sites, and Habitat in the Ohio Coastal Waters of Western Lake Erie

“…However, we observed Cohen's d-values less than 0.2 for fish community metric comparisons, and over 60 sites would have been required to achieve the appropriate statistical power. Interannual variability in species abundances and community structure can be related to water quality (Karr 1981;Ludsin et al 2001;Drake and Pereira 2002;Drake and Valley 2005), shoreline alteration (Jennings et al 1999;Toft et al 2007), and changes in lake levels (Gertzen et al 2012). The Great Lakes Fishery Commission and partnering agencies have recognized the importance of monitoring stressors and have been monitoring the lower trophic levels ) and habitat (Weimer et al 2015) in coastal and nearshore zones.…”

An Ecological Accounting System for Integrated Aquatic Planning and Habitat Banking with Case Study on the Toronto Waterfront, Ontario, Canada

“…Once a full survey and accounting of the habitat supply or natural capital (e.g., Gertzen et al 2012, Hooper et al 2019) within a habitat banking service area is completed, some areas can be set aside a priori as protected natural capital reserves, and no longer be available for trading. Only the areas remaining outside the reserves would be accessible for trading purposes.…”

Effects of water level regulation in alpine hydropower reservoirs: an ecosystem perspective with a special emphasis on fish

“…Thus, a temporal match between water levels and the timing of spawning or development of early life stages may be crucial for the reproductive success of fish in reservoirs. How exactly fish are affected depends on the species' spawning season and habitats (Gertzen et al, 2012;Linløkken & Sandlund, 2016). Physical deterioration of littoral spawning grounds due to flushing, erosion, drying and freezing of the littoral zone is detrimental for both littoral spring-and autumnspawning fishes (Kahl et al, 2008).…”