Efficacy and safety of Shi-style cervical manipulation therapy for treating acute and subacute neck pain: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Background Neck pain is a common clinical disease, which seriously affects people’s mental health and quality of life and results in loss of social productivity. Improving neck pain’s curative effect and reducing its recurrence rate are major medical problems. Shi’s manipulation therapy has unique advantages and technical features that aid in the diagnosis and treatment of neck pain. Compared with first-line non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) treatment of neck pain, Shi’s cervical manipulation lacks the relevant research basis of therapeutic advantage, safety, and satisfaction for treating acute and subacute neck pain. Herein, we aim to confirm our hypothesis in a clinical trial that the safety and efficacy of Shi’s cervical manipulation will be more effective, safer, and more satisfactory than NSAIDs to treat acute and subacute neck pain. Methods In this multicenter, positive-controlled, randomized clinical trial, traditional analgesic drug (NSAID) is used to evaluate and show that Shi’s manipulation is more effective, safe, and satisfactory for treating acute and subacute neck pain. Overall, 240 subjects are randomly divided into the trial and control groups, with both groups treated by the corresponding main intervention method for up to 12 weeks. Clinical data will be collected before the intervention and immediately after the first treatment; at 3 days and 1, 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks after the intervention; and at 26 and 52 weeks after treatment follow-up of clinical observation index data collection. The clinical observation indices are as follows: (1) cervical pain is the primary observation index, measured by Numerical Rating Scale. The secondary indices include the following: (2) cervical dysfunction index, measured by patient self-evaluation using cervical Neck Disability Index; (3) cervical activity measurement, measured by the cervical vertebra mobility measurement program of Android mobile phone system; (4) overall improvement, measured by patient self-evaluation with SF-36; and (5) satisfactory treatment, determined by patient self-evaluation. Discussion We will discuss whether Shi’s cervical manipulation has greater advantages in efficacy, safety, and satisfaction of acute and subacute neck pain than traditional NSAIDs, to provide a scientific basis for the dissemination and application of Shi’s cervical manipulation. Trial registration China Registered Clinical Trial Registration Center ChiCTR1900021371. Registered on 17 February 2019

The Changes of Brain Function After Spinal Manipulation Therapy in Patients with Chronic Low Back Pain: A Rest BOLD fMRI Study

“…The effectiveness and safety of manipulation analgesia have been clinically proven. 27 In recent years, the research of analgesic mechanism in manipulation has gradually shifted from the pathological structural changes 28,29 to the changes of pain neural pathway. 30 As far as the current studies are concerned, SMT works mainly through intervention of pain signal uploading, central pain signal processing, and feedback and suppression of pain signal to affect the pain neural pathway.…”

Definition and classification for adverse events following spinal and peripheral joint manipulation and mobilization: A scoping review

“…Variation in terms of frequency and severity, ranging from the more frequent minor/benign adverse events to rare and serious adverse events Zhang et al 2021 [108] Protocol "Shedding criteria: 1) intolerable adverse reactions; 2) serious adverse reactions; 3) the patients' pain continued to increase, which proved that trial participation was not suitable; 4) the patient's health may be damaged (for example, serious complications)'' NRS: numeric rating scale; SMT = spinal manipulative therapy.…”

Quality of Life in Patients with Low Back Pain After Chiropractic Instrumental Manipulation–A Case Study

“…Pain management approaches vary widely [9]. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, opioids, neurotropic drugs, or steroid injections and surgery are the main tools used in treatment [10]. Another approach method for the treatment of low back pain is Chiropractic Instrumental Manipulation.…”

“…Thus, specific adjustments promote the activation of micro-movements and unlock the joints through small impacts on specific points [11]. It is a technique indicated for the treatment of biomechanical restrictions, postural disorders, acute and chronic pain [10,12].…”