Lyme disease is the most prevalent vector-borne disease in the U.S., and acaricidal feeds administered to whitetailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) have potential to disrupt blood feeding by the blacklegged tick, Ixodes scapularis. Two studies were conducted with the aim of determining an ideal formulation to deliver oral acaricides to white-tailed deer and finding the lowest fipronil dose level to effectively control I. scapularis. During formulation screening, various commercial attractants (baits) were presented to deer in large paddocks under semi-field conditions and motion-sensitive cameras were used to monitor consumption by deer and non-target species. During dose range-finding, deer were housed individually and presented a fipronil feed at one of five dose levels for 48 h (two deer untreated). At 24 h post-exposure, the deer were anesthetized, blood was drawn, and deer were manually infested with 20 I. scapularis mating pairs in feeding capsules. Tick mortality was monitored up to nine days post-attachment. Results of formulation screening indicated that loose/granular formulations were substantially more palatable to deer, relative to block formulations, and would be more effective under field conditions. Dose range-finding concluded fipronil feeds with doses of 25 ppm and higher would eliminate 100% of I. scapularis parasitizing deer. Additionally, 10 ppm fipronil feed controlled a considerable proportion of ticks, and results suggested 100% ticks could be eliminated if fipronil sulfone was present in plasma at ≥25.1 ppb. These results were paramount in developing a low dose fipronil deer feed for tick control and should provide valuable insights prior to execution of future field trials.