The renewable energy-driven valorization of excess feedstocks into commodity chemicals and societally useful products constitutes a longstanding push in energy and sustainability research. To this end, this work pushes to expand the scope of green electrosynthesis by innovating a new approach to convert acetonitrile, industrially generated in excess and burned off, to in-demand ammonia and acetaldehyde products. Success here was enabled through the use of a Pd-membrane based reactor which abstracted hydrogen atoms from water, which subsequently diffused through to a separate organic compartment in which they carried out the hydrogenation reaction. In this geometry, the reaction proceeded at 5.2 mA/cm2 partial current density and 60% Faradaic efficiency towards ammonia generation. Further, the transmembrane hydrogenation approach gave rise to an onset potential of 0.2VAg/AgCl, surpassing previous state-of-the-art systems by 0.7V. A customized infrared spectroelectrochemcal setup was built up to probe the mechanism of the reaction, which was shown to proceed through an imine hydrolysis like pathway, with the hydrogenation of the NHx species that remained being the rate-limiting steps in the process. This work establishes a new route in electrochemical nitrile hydrogenation and general opens up promising avenues in green electrosynthesis.