Isolation
of substances by liquid-phase microextraction (LPME)
or electromembrane extraction (EME) is becoming more and more important
in analytical chemistry. However, the understanding of the mass transfer
in LPME and EME is limited, especially for highly concentrated samples.
In this work, the mass transfer in LPME and EME from aqueous samples
(0.5–200 mg L–1) was studied in terms of
recovery, equilibrium time, flux, and mass transfer capacity. In both
EME and LPME, high recoveries were achieved at low analyte concentration,
and the recoveries decreased at high analyte concentration. For EME,
the loss in recovery was partly compensated by increasing the extraction
voltage (from 50 to 200 V), while the LPME recovery at high analyte
concentration was improved by increasing the extraction time (from
30 to 180 min). EME was superior in terms of equilibrium time and
flux, while LPME provided much higher mass transfer capacity especially
for highly concentrated samples. Moreover, the recovery was much more
sensitive to high analyte concentrations in EME than in LPME, and
the EME recovery decreased significantly above 50 mg L–1, indicating that LPME could be used to isolate analytes in a wider
concentration range than EME. We believe that this fundamental study
will be of great importance for the selection of a suitable membrane-based
microextraction technique.