The enterobacterium Escherichia coli synthesizes two H 2 uptake enzymes, Hyd-1 and Hyd-2. We show using precise electrochemical kinetic measurements that the properties of Hyd-1 and Hyd-2 contrast strikingly, and may be individually optimized to function under distinct environmental conditions. Hyd-2 is well suited for fast and efficient catalysis in more reducing environments, to the extent that in vitro it behaves as a bidirectional hydrogenase. In contrast, Hyd-1 is active for H 2 oxidation under more oxidizing conditions and cannot function in reverse. Importantly, Hyd-1 is O 2 tolerant and can oxidize H 2 in the presence of air, whereas Hyd-2 is ineffective for H 2 oxidation under aerobic conditions. The results have direct relevance for physiological roles of Hyd-1 and Hyd-2, which are expressed in different phases of growth. The properties that we report suggest distinct technological applications of these contrasting enzymes.Hydrogenases catalyze the reversible cleavage of H 2 into protons and electrons, and play an important role in the energy metabolism of a broad range of microorganisms (1). Hydrogenases are classified according to their active site metal ion content, and three phylogenetically distinct classes have so far been identified: di-iron [FeFe]-, nickel-iron [NiFe]-, and mono-iron [Fe]-hydrogenases (1). Nickel-iron hydrogenases are the most abundant of the three types (1), and many members of this class are membrane bound, with the membrane-extrinsic domain consisting of a large subunit containing the active site, and a small subunit accommodating one to three electron-transferring iron-sulfur clusters. The active sites of [NiFe]-hydrogenases contain a nickel atom coordinated by four cysteine-S ligands, two of which bridge to an iron atom that is further coordinated by three unusual diatomic ligands, two cyanides and one carbonyl (2).Hydrogenases are inactivated by O 2