We report experimental and theoretical results for associative detachment (AD) of D − + D → D2 + e − . We compare these data to our previously published results for H − + H → H2 + e − . The measurements show no significant isotope effect in the total cross section. This is to be contrasted with previously published experimental and theoretical work which has found a significant isotope effect in diatomic systems for partial AD cross sections, i.e., as a function of the rotational and vibrational levels of the final molecule formed. Our work implies that though the ro-vibrational distribution of flux is different for AD of H − + H and D − + D, the total flux for these two systems is essentially the same when summed over all possible final channels.