Electronic support groups for breast carcinoma

Abstract

BACKGROUNDA recent Pew Charitable Trust study found that 52,000,000 individuals used the Internet to obtain health/medical information. Clinical trials of face‐to‐face breast carcinoma support groups show evidence of 1) improvement in quality of life, 2) reduction of psychologic symptoms, 3) improvement in coping responses, and 4) a reduction in pain. To the authors' knowledge, a few studies published to date have investigated Internet‐delivered electronic support groups (ESGs) for cancer. The most sophisticated is the Comprehensive Health Enhancement Support System (CHESS) program, which provides integrated information, referral, and a newsgroup‐based social support program. However, to the authors' knowledge, no studies published to date have examined the impact of a breast carcinoma ESG in a clinical trial.METHODSSixty‐seven women completed the initial baseline questionnaires, 32 of whom accepted the authors' invitation and began the groups. With regard to geographic location, 49% lived in rural/small towns, 41% lived in medium‐sized cities, and 10% lived in large cities. Diagnostic stages of disease were: Stage I, 22%; Stage II, 56%; Stage III, 12%; and other forms, 10%. There were 4 intervention groups, of which 8 participants led by trained Wellness Community (TWC) (a national agency) leaders met for 1.5 hours once a week for 16 weeks. Student t tests for paired outcome data were computed using baseline and postgroup scores.RESULTSThe results of the current study indicated that breast carcinoma patients significantly reduced depression (Center for Epidemiologic Studies‐Depression [CES‐D] scale) and Reactions to Pain. They also demonstrated a trend toward increases on The Posttraumatic Growth Inventory (PTGI) in two subscales: New Possibilities and Spirituality. Counterintuitively, breast carcinoma patients appeared to demonstrate an increase in emotional suppression. Postinterview results indicated that approximately 67% of patients found the group to be beneficial. Those who withdrew from the groups (20%) demonstrated low scores in their ability to contain anxiety and appeared to be more likely to suppress their thoughts and feelings regarding their illness.CONCLUSIONSThe findings of the current study are encouraging, particularly because it was conducted through TWC, a national agency willing to make this type of intervention readily available at no cost. A limitation of the current study was the lack of randomization and a control group comparison. Although the authors were not able to demonstrate effectiveness without the addition of a control condition, the analysis of pregroup and postgroup outcomes suggests that a randomized trial is worthwhile. Women with a devastating disease will join and commit themselves to an online support group. In addition, because a large percentage of these women were from rural locations, this type of intervention may hold promise for those who have limited access to support groups. Cancer 2003;97:920–5. © 2003 American Cancer Society.DOI 10.1002/cncr.11145

Are online support groups always beneficial? A qualitative exploration of the empowering and disempowering processes of participation within HIV/AIDS-related online support groups

“…This was evidenced by participants' descriptions of how the anonymous nature of online support groups allowed them to express themselves more openly and receive more honest responses from other members. Our findings are consistent with previous research which has shown that online support groups serve as a useful venue where members can both offer and receive emotional support (Bar-Lev, 2008;Han, et al, 2008;Lieberman et al, 2003).…”

Evaluation of CancerChatCanada: A Program of Online Support for Canadians Affected by Cancer

“…That finding challenges a belief held by many health care professionals that Internet-based social relationships are inherently superficial, tenuous, and lacking commitment 31,37 . Participation rates in online groups vary and can be low, but participation rates in our osgs were comparable or better than have been reported for other online group interventions 26,38,39 and for other face-to-face group interventions 13 . Participants communicated absences (which were usually of a medical nature) and described unexpectedly strong feelings of kinship toward their fellow osg members.…”

Enhancing psychosocial care for people with cancer in rural communities: what can remote counselling offer?

“…A similar study reported on the clinical outcomes Rehabilitation, Disability and Ageing for 32 women with breast cancer who participated in professionally facilitated and "closed" OSGs for 1.5 hours weekly over 16 weeks. 92 Improvements were made in depression and reactions to pain. Half were unable to participate due to scheduling difficulties.…”