Electronic Tracking Devices for People With Dementia: Content Analysis of Company Websites

Abstract

Background Electronic tracking devices, also known as locators, monitors, or surveillance devices, are increasingly being used to manage dementia-related wandering and, subsequently, raising various ethical questions. Despite the known importance technology design has on the ethics of technologies, little research has focused on the companies responsible for the design and development of electronic tracking devices. This paper is the first to perform a qualitative analysis of the ethically related content of the websites of companies that design and develop electronic tracking devices. Objective The aim of this study was to understand how companies that design, develop, and market electronic tracking devices for dementia care frame, through textual marketing content, the vulnerabilities and needs of persons with dementia and caregivers, the way in which electronic tracking devices respond to these vulnerabilities and needs, and the ethical issues and values at stake. Methods Electronic tracking device company websites were identified via a Google search, 2 device recommendation lists (Alzheimer’s Los Angeles and the Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health), and the 2 recent reviews of wander management technology by Neubauer et al and Ray et al. To be included, websites must be official representations of companies (not market or third-party websites) developing and selling electronic tracking devices for use in dementia care. The search was conducted on December 22, 2020, returning 199 websites excluding duplicates. Data synthesis and analysis were conducted on the textual content of the included websites using a modified form of the Qualitative Analysis Guide of Leuven. Results In total, 29 websites met the inclusion criteria. Most (15/29, 52%) companies were in the United States. The target audience of the websites was largely caregivers. A range of intertwined vulnerabilities facing persons with dementia and their caregivers were identified, and the companies addressed these via care tools that centered on certain values such as providing information while preserving privacy. Life after device implementation was characterized as a world aspired to that sees increased safety for persons with dementia and peace of mind for caregivers. Conclusions The way electronic tracking device content is currently conveyed excludes persons with dementia as a target audience. In presenting their products as a response to vulnerabilities, particular values are linked to design elements. A limitation of the results is the opaque nature of website content origins. How or when values arise in the process of design, development, and marketing is unknown. Therefore, further research should explore the process companies use to identify vulnerabilities, how values are decided upon and integrated into the design of products, and the perceptions of developers regarding the ethics of electronic tracking devices.

Vulnerability, Embodiment and Emerging Technologies: A Still Open Issue

“…Notes 1 A prime example is the use of emerging technologies (e.g., wearable devices, socially assistive robots, and virtual reality) in aged care, particularly for seniors with cognitive disorders, such as dementia. On this topic, Howes et al [5] provide a content analysis of company websites of wearable devices for people with dementia. In [6], a systematic review of argument-based ethics literature concerning the use of electronic tracking devices in dementia care is provided.…”

“…The term trans-human was coined by futurist FM-2030 5 in 1989 to refer to the "transitional man" [15], that is, Homo Sapiens enhancing their bodies and minds through the use of cyborg technologies 6 , including cosmetic surgery, bodybuilding, drugs (cognitive enhancers, mood enhancers, psychotropic drugs), genetic, biological, neuro-cognitive interventions [4,14], and brain-computer interfaces 7 . As Palazzani comments, from a critical perspective, the machinization of man and the humanization of the machine are delineated.…”

Wearable with integrated piezoelectric energy harvester for geolocation of people with Alzheimer's

“…Dementia currently affects 46.8 million people worldwide [1]. People with dementia are generally dependent on caregivers, as they require specialized care and constant monitoring as wandering is a particular problem [2]. Of the cases of dementia, Alzheimer's disease is one of the most outstanding that affects neurological functions and is still incurable, it is characterized by being a syndrome generally of a chronic or progressive nature [3] that causes the person to be disoriented and have problems to remember your address and location [4].…”