“…In assessing the extent of carbon-hydrogen bond breaking, and interpreting in terms of a mechanism in which carbon-chlorine heterolysis is running ahead of carbon-hydrogen heterolysis, we are on a scale of roughly 2.6:6 and not, as in most previous investigations, of roughly 1:6. With this in mind, the value of 3.8 is comparable with the values of between 2 and 3 observed for halide ion promoted elimination from tertiary -halogenated ketones in acetonitrile. 13 Under the same conditions of temperature and solvent, the deuterium isotope effect is significantly higher than the value of 2.62 ± 0.02 observed for El reaction.1 This is consistent with a loose intermediate or transition state (approaching an ion triplet) and incorporating a moderate weakening of a carbon-hydrogen bond in the transition state of the rate-determining step.13 If a transition state was involved which featured only Sn2 character superimposed upon a El-type process, then one might expect, related to the extent that the positive charge on the a carbon was reduced, an isotope effect for the bimolecular reaction diminished below that observed for the El reaction.…”