Introduction: In this study, we compare glycosylation at the feto-maternal interface in 3 equine species: horse, donkey and zebra, all of which can interbreed to produce hybrids, to assess their glycan similarities and differences. Methods: Sections cut from 3 specimens of horse (Equus caballus) placenta (50, 200 and 280 days gestation), one donkey (Equus asinus) placenta (65cm crown-rump length) and 5 specimens of zebra (Equus quagga) placentae (81 to 239 days gestation) were stained with a panel of 24 biotinylated lectins using an avidin-peroxidase revealing system. Results: There were only slight quantitative differences in the lectin histochemistry at the feto-maternal interface between all three specimens; zebra placentae expressed more α2,6-linked sialic acid, with α1,2fucosyl residues at the microvillous interface. However, zebra trophoblast showed histological differences from the other two species, with polarised cells, prominent supranuclear Golgi bodies, and fewer intracellular granules. Discussion: Our findings appear to confirm the hypothesis that closely related, interbreeding species with epitheliochorial placentae express similar glycans at the feto-maternal interface, thereby supporting the existence of a placental glycocode. We also observed intraspecies evolutionary diversion to be associated with a different histological architecture and the absence of significant intracellular granules.
Response to ReviewersReviewer #1: I do not think that the first sentence in the abstract is justified.It should be removed. All of the important results of the glycoconjugate comparisons have been carried out on mid to late gestation material. They form an important and scientifically useful comparison of species differences and similarities. They measure the expression at the microvillar junction, trophoblast and uterine epithelium together. Noonehas shown the expression of glycoconjugates on the separate maternal and embryonic surfaces at implantation to validate or otherwise the "glycocode" hypothesis.The rest of the paper is now modified suitably. As suggested by this reviewer, we have removed the first sentence and modified the text appropriately: "In this study, we compare glycosylation at the fetomaternal interface in 3 equine species: horse, donkey and zebra, all of which can interbreed to produce hybrids, to assess their glycan similarities and differences." Reviewer #3: There is an adequate response to the points raised by Reviewer #1 and a rebuttal of the concerns raised by Reviewer #2. I share some of this reviewer's reservations, which arise directly from the interpretation of the lectin histochemistry being dependent a single author.Two additional points that must be dealt with before publication:1) The Figure legends should define the abbreviations used in the figures, e.g. MVM. This has been addressed, with addition of more labels in Figure 2.2) The authors are selective in mentioning only embryo transfer from the bovine to sheep or goats, which are classified in separate subfamilies...