Embedding Critical Thinking in IS Curricula

Abstract

Executive SummaryIt is important for students to develop critical thinking and other higher-order thinking skills during their tertiary studies. Along with the ability to think critically comes the need to develop students' meta-cognitive skills. These abilities work together to enable students to control, monitor, and regulate their own cognitive processes and improve their ability to comprehend and solve problems.This paper proposes the use of scaffolding as a method of helping students to develop their critical thinking and meta-cognitive skills within the IS curriculum. Scaffolding enables students to undertake tasks that they might not have been able to tackle without the scaffolding. It allows the learners to focus on the aspects of the task that they can manage, while still keeping an understanding of the task as a whole. As the scaffolding is gradually removed, the student should be able to work more independently and apply the new skills effectively.The paper shows how the scaffolding of the process of critical thinking can be used in the early stages of the IS curriculum to enable students to first learn, then gain confidence, in using the techniques that they need to apply independently in the latter stages of the curriculum. Some of the topics covered and where skills were developed included writing essays (in particular essays that include argument), critical and analytical thinking in programming, and the use of problemsolving techniques in systems analysis and design.In the section on critical and analytical thinking in programming, we show how we taught students to think logically and then how this was applied in programming. The task of testing algorithms was scaffolded to enable the students to learn how to evaluate a program and create test data. The paper then shows how the lecturer developed students' meta-cognitive skills by phrasing SQL questions that made the students conscious of their thinking and helped them to link what they were currently doing with their previous knowledge.The paper goes on to show how the conventional problem-solving techniques that are often taught to school children can be used in systems analysis and design. These techniques help the student to consider the whole picture and to understand the relationships between the different parts of the system and how it interacts with the rest of the world.Lastly, the paper describes how the students were taught to write and argue when writing an academic essay. The first assessment task was carefully scaffolded to help the students understand the need to put forward an argument, substantiate that argument and to miniMaterial published as part of this publication, either on-line or in print, is copyrighted by the Informing Science Institute. Permission to make digital or paper copy of part or all of these works for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that the copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage AND that copies 1) bear this notice in full and 2) give the full citation o...

Generic competences acquisition through classroom activities in first-year agricultural engineering students

“…Moreover, students were provided with opportunities for self-assessment, peer dialogue and engagement with feedback from teachers. These good results reinforce the idea that the framework provided by the teacher to study the problem acts as a scaffold to support immediate knowledge construction by learners (Thomas, Davis, & Kazlauskas, 2007). Students also had the chance to solve the new exercises proposed by the teacher at home and were provided with only the final solution.…”

Teaching High School Students Applied Logical Reasoning

“…However, our results indicate that there is abundant potential for improvement in students' thinking skills. Thus, we believe that this course should be an introductory course and that training in thinking skills must be provided throughout the entire student curriculum in a similar manner to the recent suggestions made by Thomas et al (2007).…”

“…Studying critical thinking in high school allows students to incorporate these skills into their learning process at an earlier age, thereby providing continuity and a strong foundation from which to expand during college level instruction, ultimately resulting in greater skill retention. This approach can be coupled with the scaffolding approach of Thomas, Davis, and Kazlauskas (2007), which is implemented in a variety of college courses.…”

Teaching digital electronics course for electrical engineering students in cognitive domain

“…These skills include problem analysis and problem solving, project management and leadership, analytical skills and critical thinking, dissemination and communication, interdisciplinary competencies, intercultural communication, innovation and creativity, and social abilities (Kuru, 2007). Critical thinking is a crucial skill that the students need to develop during their undergraduate study, in order to deal with the real-life and authentic EEE problems (Reif & Scott, 1999;Thomas, Davis & Kazlauskas, 2007).…”