Emergency medicine physician burnout before and during the COVID-19 pandemic

Abstract

Background Burnout is a common issue among physicians, and the rate among emergency medicine physicians (EPs) appears to be higher than those of other medical specialties. The COVID-19 pandemic presents unprecedented challenges to the medical community worldwide, but its effects on EP burnout has not yet been determined. Methods We conducted a three-stage nationwide study between July 2019 and June 2021. First, we evaluated the responses to burnout questionnaires that had been filled in by EP before the COVID-19 pandemic. We then re-sent the same questionnaires, with an addition of pandemic-specific questions. The third step involved a small group of EPs who participated in a burnout reduction workshop and re-took the questionnaires after a 3-month interval. The Maslach Burnout Inventory measured three burnout scales and a Work and Meaning Inventory predicts job satisfaction. Descriptive, univariate, and multivariate statistical tests were used to analyze the data. Results In the first stage, 240 questionnaires were sent by email to all Israeli EPs listed in emergency departments nationwide, and 84 out of 88 submitted questionnaires were completed in full before the pandemic. 393 questionnaires were sent in the second stage during the pandemic and 93 out of 101 submitted questionnaires were completed in full. Twenty EPs participated in the workshop and 13 out of 20 submitted questionnaires were completed in full. Burnout levels were high (Maslach) among EPs before the pandemic and increased during the pandemic. The feelings of personal accomplishment and work meaning—both protective factors from burnout—were significantly higher in the second (pandemic) stage. The pandemic-specific burnout factors were fear of infecting family members, lack of care centers for the physician’s children, increased workload, and insufficient logistic support. The physician-oriented intervention had no significant impact on burnout levels (p < 0.412, Friedman test). Conclusions Physician burnout is a major global problem, and it is now being aggravated by the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic. Healthcare administrators should be alerted to pandemic-specific stress factors in order to help teams cope better and to prevent further worsening of the burnout. Further research is warranted to determine the lasting effect of the pandemic on EM physician burnout and the best means for reducing it.

Profile of Eye-Related Emergency Department Visits in Ontario – A Canadian Perspective

“…[18,19] The results of this investigation are of particular importance given the increase in burnout seen by ED providers from the COVID-19 pandemic. [20,21] As we enter into the post-COVID-19 era, restructuring acute care delivery systems may be an effective approach to help more effectively meet patients' needs while reducing the burden on already overwhelmed EDs.…”

Prevalence of Burnout Among Public Health Professionals: A Systematic Review

“…Based on our findings, burnout among public health may be similar in magnitude to that experienced by clinical care professionals, though much greater and more extensive amount of research has been conducted assessing burnout in clinical care, along with development and implementation of interventions. 2,3,7 Clearly, both public health and clinical care providers are experiencing greater burdens of burnout, which has the potential to adversely affect the delivery of health promotion/disease prevention and clinical care across the nation and around the world and there is a need for governments to address resiliency among both more holistically, rather than focusing on 1 group over the other.…”

“…1 A growing body of literature indicates the COVID-19 pandemic magnified already prevalent stress and burnout rates among general health professionals, and to what extent this holds true for public health professionals remains to be determined. 2,3 The term "burnout" was first coined in 1970 by American psychologist Herbert Freudenberg. He used this term to describe severe and chronic stress in the "helping" professions, such as nurses and doctors.…”

“…Acknowledging the widespread adverse work experience even before the COVID-19 pandemic, the World Health Organization (WHO) declared burnout as an “occupational phenomenon,” and the term was included in the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases 1. A growing body of literature indicates the COVID-19 pandemic magnified already prevalent stress and burnout rates among general health professionals, and to what extent this holds true for public health professionals remains to be determined 2,3…”

Review of pediatric emergency care and the COVID‐19 pandemic

“…The COVID-19 pandemic has had a substantial impact on the wellness of pre-hospital and hospital-based health care professionals, with many reporting high levels of emotional exhaustion and burnout. [83][84][85][86] Despite initial lower ED volumes on shifts, pediatric emergency physicians experienced heightened stress and anxiety due to multiple contributing factors including availability of PPE, risk of infection to themselves and their families, guilt about colleagues in the adult ED (perceived to be experiencing more stress in the ED as a result of the pandemic), and concern about job stability or salary decreases due to unknown pediatric volumes. 15…”