Emergency Physician Estimation of Blood Loss

Abstract

IntroductionEmergency physicians (EP) frequently estimate blood loss, which can have implications for clinical care. The objectives of this study were to examine EP accuracy in estimating blood loss on different surfaces and compare attending physician and resident performance.MethodsA sample of 56 emergency department (ED) physicians (30 attending physicians and 26 residents) were asked to estimate the amount of moulage blood present in 4 scenarios: 500 mL spilled onto an ED cot; 25 mL spilled onto a 10-pack of 4 × 4-inch gauze; 100 mL on a T-shirt; and 150 mL in a commode filled with water. Standard estimate error (the absolute value of (estimated volume − actual volume)/actual volume × 100) was calculated for each estimate.ResultsThe mean standard error for all estimates was 116% with a range of 0% to 1233%. Only 8% of estimates were within 20% of the true value. Estimates were most accurate for the sheet scenario and worst for the commode scenario. Residents and attending physicians did not perform significantly differently (P > 0.05).ConclusionEmergency department physicians do not estimate blood loss well in a variety of scenarios. Such estimates could potentially be misleading if used in clinical decision making. Clinical experience does not appear to improve estimation ability in this limited study.

Blood Loss Estimation in Small Animals and Assessment of a Pictorial Tool to Improve Accuracy in a Global Population of Veterinary Anesthesia Staff

“…Our results indicated no difference between the role groups. This is contrary to Ashburn et al (38) who found that attending physician had a reduced error compared with residents. Our finding is, however, similar to Adkins et al (5) who investigated groups of anesthesia providers and found no difference between different roles and levels of experience and expertise.…”

Measurement of Intraoperative Blood Loss in Pediatric Orthopaedic Patients: Evaluation of a New Method

“…The visualization method requires suppositions dependent on blood loss found in suction canisters, surgical sponges, surgical drapes/surgical gowns, and the operating room environment (ie, operating room floor). 18 This method has been found to be inaccurate for estimating blood loss in many studies 11 , 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 that show that physicians underestimate blood loss in high blood loss situations and overestimate in low blood loss situations. 9 , 11 , 18…”

Elucidating the clinical characteristics of patients captured using different definitions of massive transfusion

“…As estimated blood loss is an inherently unreliable and often underestimated , CB was defined as any patient identified by a definition of MT. Reports of all RBC units issued (including date and time) and transfused in calendar year 2010 were obtained from hospital blood banks.…”