Emotional Mimicry in Social Context: The Case of Disgust and Pride

Abstract

A recent review on facial mimicry concludes that emotional mimicry is less ubiquitous than has been suggested, and only occurs in interactions that are potentially affiliative (see Hess and Fischer, in revision). We hypothesize that individuals do not mimic facial expressions that can be perceived as offensive, such as disgust, and mimic positive emotion displays, but only when the context is affiliative (i.e., with intimates). Second, we expect that in spontaneous interactions not mimicry, but empathic feelings with the other predict the accurateness of emotion recognition. Data were collected in a pseudo-experimental setting, during an event organized for subscribers of a large Dutch women’s magazine. One woman (expresser) was exposed to two emotional stimuli (i.e., a vile smell, a compliment) in order to evoke disgust and pride respectively. Another woman (observer: intimate or stranger) was sitting opposite of her. We collected self-report measures on emotions and empathy, and coded facial expressions of disgust and smiling on the basis of FACS. The results show that participants do not mimic disgust. In contrast, smiles displayed after the vile smell and the compliment were mimicked, but only among intimates. We also found that self-reported empathy and not mimicry is related to the recognition of disgust. These findings are discussed in the light of a Social Contextual view on emotional mimicry.

The Pacified Face: Early Embodiment Processes and the Use of Dummies

“…In particular, studies in which facial mimicry of perceived expressions was measured rather than blocked (e.g. Hess and Blairy, 2001;Fischer et al, 2012a) did not show associations between facial movements and accuracy of emotion recognition. The same was true for studies in which recognition tasks employed prototypical facial expressions (e.g.…”

Mimicking non-verbal emotional expressions and empathy development in simulated consultations: An experimental feasibility study

“…Emotional mimicry is thus the imitation of an emotional intention, rather than the movement of facial muscles. Emotional mimicry will therefore occur only if the emotional signal and the relationship are perceived as affiliative [25]. In support of this social-contextual view of emotional mimicry, many clinicians in our study felt uncomfortable being instructed to mimic.…”

Does the ability to express different emotions predict different indices of physical health? A skill‐based study of physical symptoms and heart rate variability

“…However, with the exception of one recent report (Tuck, Grant, Sollers, et al, 2016), studies have operationalized expressive skills in terms of broad positive or negative valence and have not looked at the ability to flexibly regulate specific emotions. Discrete emotions have precise signals that serve specific functions within the social environment (e.g., Fischer, Becker, & Veenstra, 2012;Fischer & Roseman, 2007;Keltner, 1995). Consequently, some emotions may be more closely related to physical health than others (Tuck, Grant, Jackson, Brooks, & Consedine, 2016;Tuck, Grant, Sollers, et al, 2016), and valence-based assessments of positive/negative expressivity may obscure emotionspecific links.…”