Emotional Numbness Modifies the Effect of End-of-Life Discussions on End-of-Life Care

Abstract

Context Overall, end-of-life (EOL) discussions are unrelated to psychological distress and associated with lower rates of aggressive care near death. Nevertheless, patients who report they feel emotionally numb about their illness might encounter difficulties cognitively processing an EOL discussion. Objectives We hypothesized that emotional numbness would modify the influence of EOL discussions on the receipt of less aggressive EOL care. Methods Data were derived from structured interviews with 290 participants in the federally-funded Coping with Cancer Study, a multisite, prospective cohort study of advanced cancer patients followed through their death. Patients’ reports of EOL discussions with their physician and emotional numbness were assessed a median of 4.6 months before death. Information about aggressive EOL care (i.e., ventilation, resuscitation in the last week of life, death in the Intensive Care Unit) was obtained from postmortem caregiver interviews and medical charts. Main and interactive effects of EOL discussions and emotional numbness on aggressive EOL care, adjusting for potential confounds, were evaluated using multiple logistic regression. Results The likelihood of aggressive EOL care associated with having EOL discussions increased by a factor of nine (adjusted odds ratio=9.02, 95% confidence interval 1.37, 59.6, P=0.022) for every unit increase in a patient’s emotional numbness score. Conclusion Emotional numbness diminishes a patient’s capacity to benefit from EOL discussions. EOL decision making may be more effective if clinical communications with emotionally numb patients are avoided.

Family members’ perceptions of inpatient palliative care consult services: A qualitative study

“…29 Increased effort is needed to encourage referring physician participation in some aspect of the consultation or form a strong collaboration with the physician to improve the family experience. 30 Family members' readiness for both attending the family meeting and receiving complete information about the patient's health and disease trajectory was a striking finding from this study. While another palliative care study has documented that some patients felt they received too much information about the patient's condition, 11 the theme of "readiness" has not been well documented in the literature.…”

Associations Between Personality and End-of-Life Care Preferences Among Men With Prostate Cancer: A Clustering Approach

“…One possibility is an individual higher in neuroticism may be more avoidant [28–30] of thinking deeply about impending frailty and death when faced with a threatening hypothetical scenario. In “real-world” settings, their avoidance can lead them to refrain from preparing for the future (e.g., not complete advanced directives; not engage in meaningful end-of-life conversation [31, 32]), which could subsequently lead to more intensive service utilization [33]. Alternatively, this avoidance could manifest in more neurotic individuals having lower preferences for both types of end-of-life care simply out of a general desire to be “left alone” when facing significant stressors [8].…”

Gender differences in the evolution of illness understanding among patients with advanced cancer

“…6 Many patients are in a state of shock or made emotionally numb by discussion of a terminal prognosis, 7 which may inhibit their ability to comprehend the gravity of their condition. We have reported that among cancer patients with incurable metastatic disease only 38% acknowledged being terminally ill a median of 4 months prior to death.…”