Emotional patterns in a simulated virtual classroom supported with an affective recommendation system

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to explore the effects of an affective recommendation system on the developmental trajectories of prospective teachers' emotional patterns, integrated with a Simulated Virtual Classroom (SVC) platform called SimInClass. SVC exposes teachers to a range of student discourses in the form of unexpected stimuli. Fifteen prospective teachers participated in a study consisting of two practicum sessions in the SVC. Participants did not receive any affective recommendation after the first session but did receive it after the second session. Additional data were collected during both sessions in the SVC, including the physiological responses, such as electroencephalogram (EEG), galvanic skin response (GSR), and facial expressions. L metric and Lag sequential analysis were employed in determining teachers' transitional emotional patterns. The results showed that participants did not maintain disgust after receiving affective recommendations, although they maintained sadness. This result indicates that the given affective recommendation has an inherent effect on negative emotions that are felt less intensely. Different or longer‐term interventions may be needed for more intense and long‐lasting negative discrete emotions such as sadness. Also, participants transitioned to happiness and sadness instead of maintaining their neutral status after receiving an affective recommendation. This result demonstrates that affective recommendations encourage participants to use the cognitive reappraisal necessary for emotion regulation. When the participants' emotional patterns are examined on the basis of student discourse, the results are more complex and the emotional patterns differ according to the function of the discourse triggered by virtual students. What is already known about this topic Teachers experience different emotional states during teaching. Teachers' emotions affect their behaviour management, teaching process and student engagement. It is beneficial to increase opportunities for prospective teachers' classroom experience and provide them with sufficient guidance and advice during this difficult process. What this paper adds The affective recommendation system has intervened in the persistence of short‐term and low‐intensity negative emotions. The affective recommendation system enabled prospective teachers to try to reach optimal emotional conditions through cognitive reappraisal processes. When emotional patterns are examined in light of the types of student discourse, it is noted that happy prospective teachers maintain their emotions when confronted with unexpected stimuli. However, prospective teachers in a negative valance displayed a descending pattern of activation in response to an unexpected stimulus. Implications for practice and/or policy Teacher emotions need to be taken into account in teacher education programs. SVCs can be utilized as useful tools for teacher education programs. In subsequent studies, it is suggested to explore the stimulus‐based effects of t...

Uncovering emotion sequence patterns in different interaction groups using deep learning and sequential pattern mining

“…Lajoie et al (2021) explored the temporal dynamics of emotions across different groups using sequential transition diagram, revealing that low performers demonstrated greater emotional instability. Ozhan et al (2022)…”

“…Lajoie et al (2021) explored the temporal dynamics of emotions across different groups using sequential transition diagram, revealing that low performers demonstrated greater emotional instability. Ozhan et al (2022) examined the emotions and emotional patterns experienced by 15 prospective teachers through lag sequential analysis in a simulated virtual classroom. To date, few studies have used sequential pattern mining to analyse and identify emotion sequence patterns in online discussion forums.…”

“…Therefore, there is a need to deepen our understanding of leaners' emotional patterns. This is crucial because the emotions experienced are likely to affect not only their learning outcomes but also the development of the learning environment (Anttila et al, 2017; Ozhan et al, 2022). In the context of MOOC discussions, we define emotion sequence patterns as the dynamic changes in emotions that demonstrate how learners' emotions evolve over time during a learning process.…”

How does interactive virtual reality enhance learning outcomes via emotional experiences? A structural equation modeling approach

“…According to the CVTAE, the extent to which students experience a sense of control regarding educational content can produce enjoyment (Plass and Kaplan, 2016). Research conducted by Roseman andSmith (2001) andCaglar-Ozhan et al (2022) also indicates that the evaluation of control potential is a component that affects emotion directly. Thus, enjoyment can be predicted to be stronger when the learning activity in question is sufficiently controllable (Pekrun, 2006).…”