Emphasizing Learning: Using Standards-Based Grading in a Large Nonmajors’ General Chemistry Survey Course

Abstract

Many students associate grades with the completion of course work rather than learning the course content. While research has heavily focused on teaching strategies and instructional tools to improve students’ learning in general chemistry, less focus has been given to assessments as a learning tool to improve students learning. Standards-based grading (SBG) is a nontraditional assessment method that explicitly connects the learning course objectives with assessments and student grades. Provided with more than one opportunity to demonstrate their knowledge of course objectives, students are evaluated on their level of achievement of these objectives. This article describes the implementation, outcomes, and challenges of SBG in a large enrollment nonmajors’ general chemistry course. Evidence is presented regarding the use of SBG in chemistry from the evaluation of two semesters of students’ assessment scores and a student opinion survey. Students appeared to use the structure of the SBG to pass the course at higher rates than previous semesters, demonstrated some metacognitive skills, and generally appreciated SBG as the assessment method in the course.

The Effect of Specifications Grading on Students’ Learning and Attitudes in an Undergraduate-Level Cell Biology Course

“…In this system, students can retake individual assessments to achieve mastery, increasing student effort and retention and giving them more control over their grade ( 12 ). Since the introduction of specifications (specs) grading, it has been implemented in various STEM courses, including Mathematics, Physics, Anatomy and Physiology, and Chemistry ( 19 – 23 ). In each of these publications, it was noted that even though the development of the many assessments was time consuming, the grading of these assessments saved time because no partial credit was awarded.…”

Developing and Implementing a Specifications Grading System in an Organic Chemistry Laboratory Course

“…Specifications grading has been used in various STEM courses, including chemistry lecture courses, but has not yet been reported in a chemistry laboratory course. [14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][23][24][25]27,29,32 With an endgoal of scaling up specifications grading to our larger, 1,000 plus student, on-sequence courses, we chose to pilot a specifications grading system in the final course in the organic chemistry laboratory sequence. We specifically chose to pilot specifications grading in the accelerated summer session course because it has the smallest enrollment -about 40 students.…”

Developing and Implementing a Specifications Grading System in an Organic Chemistry Laboratory Course

“…Specifications grading has been used in various STEM courses, including chemistry lecture courses, but has not yet been reported in a chemistry laboratory-only course. [15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][24][25][26]28,30,33 With an end-goal of scaling up specifications grading to our larger, 1,000 plus student, on-sequence courses, we chose to pilot a specifications grading system in the final course in the organic chemistry laboratory sequence. We specifically chose to pilot specifications grading in the accelerated summer session course because it has the smallest enrollment -about 40 students.…”