Empirical Evidence of the Efficiency and Efficacy of Fat Taxes and Thin Subsidies

Abstract

This study summarizes the empirical literature on fat taxes and thin subsidies to assess their efficiency and efficacy as instruments of public policy to control obesity. Three specific types of taxes are studied in the literature: food group taxes; nutrient taxes; and nutrient index taxes. Anumber of studies use food expenditure data to assess the impact of various taxes on obesity and therefore only indirectly measure the impacts of taxes and subsidies on obesity. These studies generally conclude that food group taxes, nutrient taxes and nutrient index taxes have a small impact on the purchases of food and the nutrients purchased. Other studies use the body mass index as the explanatory variable and thus measure the impacts of taxes on body mass index directly. Nutrient taxes are found to be more effective than food group taxes, although even for nutrient taxes, the effects are small. In general, thin subsidies seem to offer more effective control of obesity than obesity taxes. However, due to the small effects of both fat taxes and thin subsidies, they are not recommended as instruments of food and nutrition policy.

Assessing the per Capita Food Supply Trends of 38 OECD Countries between 2000 and 2019—A Joinpoint Regression Analysis

“…A possible and nowadays widely used policy measure that can achieve a reduction in non-communicable diseases is the taxation of goods linked to unhealthy lifestyles, a policy that is being applied in a growing number of countries [ 61 , 62 , 63 ]. These taxes are usually based on the risk factors for chronic diseases (e.g., high-sugar foods and beverages, junk food, alcohol, tobacco, etc.)…”

Assessing the impact of Hungary's public health product tax: an interrupted time series analysis

“…The essence of Pigouvian taxes on unhealthy food or nutrients is the internalisation of the costs raised by their harmful effects (7,8). Several countries have already developed such a levy (9)(10)(11). Evidence shows that such political decisions could contribute to a decrease in the consumption of unhealthy products, thus improving the overall status of public health, the ability to work and reduce health expenditures (7).…”

A diabetes mellitus és a táplálkozási szokások egészségbiztosítási és egészség-gazdaságtani összefüggései

“…Egy lehetséges és manapság széles körben alkalmazott gazdaságpolitikai intézkedés, amely a nem fertőző betegségek csökkentését eredményezheti, az egészségtelen életmódhoz kapcsolódó termékek megadóztatása; ezt egyre több országban alkalmazzák [73,74]. Ezek az adók általában a krónikus betegségek kockázati tényezőin alapulnak (pl.…”