“…However, the conclusions of various studies are not consistent. For example, Alexandrakis and Eaton (2007) exploited the Empirical Transfer Function technique to precisely measure SmKS differential travel times and found no evidence for stratification, consistent with some other SmKS studies (e.g., Alexandrakis & Eaton, 2010;Souriau & Poupinet, 1991a). In contrast, other reports support a layer with lower Vp than that of PREM in the outermost core (e.g., Eaton & Kendall, 2006;Garnero et al, 1993;Helffrich & Kaneshima, 2010;Kaneshima & Matsuzawa, 2015;Kaneshima, 2018;Tanaka, 2004Tanaka, , 2007Tang et al, 2015), although the thickness and amplitude of the Vp anomaly varies from one study to another.…”