Empowering and Resisting in a Sharing Economy: Two Sides of the Same Coin

Abstract

Some can regard the sharing economy (SE) as a sustainable economy for allowing innovative (even disruptive) business opportunities and for encouraging new forms of consumption. There are, however, controversies about SE's role in being a commercially-oriented economy taking advantage of regulatory and market failures. Such ambiguous trajectories provide opportunities for research, and one of them brings attention to power's exercise to promote or influence change. This research, a single-case study of Uber, aims to understand the connections between framings to empower and to resist in a SE context. Three two-sided (empower and resist) perspectives -the economic system, the business market, and the sustainable-driven perspectives -and two strengthening actions -searching for legitimacy and fighting and calling for status quo -arise within the SE context analyzed. Empowering framings sounded more convincing compared to resisting ones, and resisting framings highlighted contradictions not expected from SE initiatives. Our findings suggest that SE does have the potential to stimulate a kind of nonreversible sustainable mindset, but this path choice is still unclear.

La economía colaborativa, sus beneficios y efectos

“…Al tratarse de un nuevo segmento o también un nuevo sector de la economía relacionado con tecnología e innovación, muchos países carecen de las regulaciones respectivas para hacer respetar ciertas leyes mínimas necesarias para salvaguardar a una sociedad. Por lo tanto, quedan dudas si las plataformas digitales se aprovechan de los vacíos legales de las naciones en donde se encuentran operando para aprovecharse de esa situación (Bó & Petrini, 2019).…”

UBERIZAÇÃO DO TRABALHO: a percepção dos motoristas de transporte por aplicativos na cidade de Goiânia.

“…Diversos autores buscam classificar as plataformas digitais em termos de produção ou não de valor pelo trabalho. A possibilidade de troca ou venda por meio de aplicativos conectados à internet pode ou não estabelecer relações de produção e, portanto, de exploração do trabalho (Huws, 2014;Kenney;Zysman, 2016;Srnicek, 2017;Bo;Petrini, 2019;Lima;Bridi, 2019;Accorsi, 2019).…”