“…[23,24] Although recent theoretical studies suggest that the formation of metal carbenes from α-carbonyl sulfoxonium ylides is a two-step process involving facile coordination of the ylide carbon atom to the metal followed by rate-limiting elimination of DMSO, [25] the efficiency of formation of an iridium carbene from 3, 9, 15, and 16 does not appear to fully explain their difference of reactivity. [18][19][20][21][26][27][28] Instead, it is more likely that after attack of the iridium catalyst by these substrates and elimination of DMSO from 58, iridium carbenes 59 would be formed in all cases (Figure 1c). Then, ChemCatChem dimerization [21,26] and other unidentified decomposition pathways would be predominant in the case of the six-membered ring intermediates (n = 1), whereas indole would react productively with the five-membered ring intermediates 59 (n = 0) to give 60, which would give 33 and 37 after a sequence consisting of 1,2-hydride shift to 61, elimination to 62 and rearomatization.…”