In the presence of a trityl-substituted cinchona alkaloid-based catalyst, homophthalic, aryl succinic, and glutaconic anhydride derivatives reacted with aromatic and aliphatic aldehydes to produce cis-lactones in up to 90:10 dr and 99% ee. A DFT study has shown how the catalyst is uniquely able to bring about the opposite sense of diastereocontrol to that usually observed.