In this study, the unique capacity of bifunctional Brønsted bases to generate α‐branched ketone dienolates and control both site‐ and stereoselectivity of their addition reactions to representative classes of carbon electrophiles (i.e., vinyl sulfones, nitroolefins, formaldehyde) is documented. We demonstrate that by using selected chiral tertiary amine/squaramide catalysts, the reactions of β,γ‐unsaturated cycloalkanones proceed through the dienolate Cα almost exclusively and provide all‐carbon quaternary cyclic ketone adducts in good yields with very high enantioselectivities. A minor amount (<5 %) of γ‐addition is observed when nitroolefins are used as electrophiles. The parent acyclic ketone dienolates proved to be less reactive under these conditions, and thus still constitute a challenging class of substrates. Quantum chemical calculations correctly predict these differences in reactivity and explain the observed site‐specificity and enantioselectivity.