A Cu(II)-catalyzed diastereoselective Michael/aldol cascade approach is used to accomplish concise total syntheses of cardiotonic steroids with varying degrees of oxygenation including cardenolides ouabagenin, sarmentologenin, 19-hydroxysarmentogenin, and 5-epi-panogenin. These syntheses enabled the subsequent SAR studies on 37 synthetic and natural steroids to elucidate the effect of oxygenation, stereochemistry, C3-glycosylation and C17-heterocyclic ring. Based on this parallel evaluation of synthetic and natural steroids and their derivatives, glycosylated steroids cannogenol-L-α-rhamnoside (79a), strophanthidol-L-α-rhamnoside (92), and digitoxigenin-L-α-rhamnoside (97) were identified as the most potent steroids demonstrating broad anticancer activity at 10–100 nM concentrations and selectivity (nontoxic at 3 μM against NIH-3T3, MEF and developing fish embryos). Further analyses indicate that these molecules show a general mode of anticancer activity involving DNA damage upregulation that subsequently induces apoptosis.