Encountering ethics through design: a workshop with nonhuman participants

Abstract

What if we began to speculate that intelligent things have an ethical agenda? Could we then imagine ways to move past the moral divide ‘human vs. nonhuman’ in those contexts, where things act on our behalf? Would this help us better address matters of agency and responsibility in the design and use of intelligent systems? In this article, we argue that if we fail to address intelligent things as objects that deserve moral consideration by their relations within a broad social context, we will lack a grip on the distinct ethical rules governing our interaction with intelligent things, and how to design for it. We report insights from a workshop, where we take seriously the perspectives offered by intelligent things, by allowing unforeseen ethical situations to emerge in an improvisatory manner. By giving intelligent things an active role in interaction, our participants seemed to be activated by the artifacts, provoked to act and respond to things beyond the artifact itself—its direct functionality and user experience. The workshop helped to consider autonomous behavior not as a simplistic exercise of anthropomorphization, but within the more significant ecosystems of relations, practices and values of which intelligent things are a part.

The Entoptic Field Camera as Metaphor-Driven Research-through-Design with AI Technologies

“…12 4.1.4 Decentering Conventional Scales of Representation. Morethan-human design and sustainable HCI (SHCI) are growing areas of research, frequently confronting the implicit anthropocentric narcissism of emerging technologies (see e.g., [50,56,79,89,107]).…”

Designing More-Than-Human AI: Experiments on Situated Conversations and Silences

“…The first experiment consisted of a series of workshops in 2020, in which we invited 36 designers and researchers across different fields to interview CAs, enact new interactions and materialise different embodiments (Nicenboim et al, 2020). The interviews were conducted with the smart speakers Alexa, Home, and Siri, using the method Interview with Things (Chang et al, 2017) combined with speculating responses (Reddy et al, 2020; 2021) Fig. 2.…”

More-than-human Concepts, Methodologies, and Practices in HCI

“…Scholars have also highlighted the politics and ethics of MTHD, with issues of participation [10], supporting values such as equality and justice, and including perspectives (humans and nonhumans) that have been traditionally ignored in design processes [1,16]. Some of these issues were highlighted in various design fictions [11,34,35,38,39].…”