“…On the other hand, negative arguments are raised by some researchers due to the fact that increased exports lead to increased industrial production activities, which ultimately increase CO 2 emissions and, hence, damage environmental quality [51]. Empirically, Jebli, Youssef [52], Balsalobre-Lorente, Shahbaz [37], Gasimli, Gamage [53], Mahmood, Maalel [54], Murad and Mazumder [55], Tiwari, Shahbaz [13], and Halicioglu [56], found detrimental effects of trade on the environment in 22 Central and South American countries, 5 EU countries, as well as Sri Lanka, Tunisia, Malaysia, India, and Turkey. In contrast, Khan, Ali [57] demonstrated that exports decreased and imports increased consumption-based carbon emissions in nine oil-exporting countries.…”