Enforcement Releases, Firm Characteristics, and Earnings Quality: Insights from Germany's Two‐tiered Enforcement System

Abstract

The implementation of a two-tier external enforcement mechanism in Germany in 2004 permits the examination of the interrelationship of enforcement releases, firm characteristics, and earnings quality in a unique institutional framework. A total of 151 cases are examined where the announcement of errors in prior disclosed and audited financial statements was mandatorily ordered by the enforcement authority. Prior literature documents the correlation between underperformance in financial ratios and the probability of erroneous disclosure of financial statements. Evidence is provided of differences in characteristics between firms with enforcement releases and control firms as well as all German publicly listed firms. The research affirms the connection of financial ratios to earnings quality metrics. Overall, the results document the underperformance in important financial ratios as well as indicate an inferior earnings quality of firms subject to enforcement releases vis-a-vis the control groups. These results hold with regard to both different earnings quality specifications and different periods observed. This study adds to the earnings quality discussion and contributes to the development of a comprehensive picture of accounting quality in the unique institutional settings of Germany. The findings show that a conjoint two-tier public and private enforcement system is effective and could be a model for consideration by other countries.

Disclosure, Enforcement and the Valuation of Equity

“…Literature associates the introduction of more regulation typically with a higher information level and predicts a positive effect on liquidity, cost of equity and equity valuation (e.g. ; (Lambert et al 2007); (Strohmenger 2014); (Verrecchia 2001)).…”