Engaging Older Adults in Health Care Decision-Making: A Realist Synthesis

Abstract

BackgroundEngagement in healthcare decision making has been recognized as an important, and often lacking, aspect of care, especially in the care of older adults who are major users of the healthcare system.ObjectiveWe aimed to conduct a review of available knowledge on engagement in healthcare decision making with a focus on older patients and their caregivers.MethodsWe conducted a realist synthesis focusing on strategies for engagement of older patients and their caregivers in healthcare decision making. The synthesis encompassed theoretical frameworks and both peer-reviewed and grey literature. Expert consultations included interviews (n = 2) with academics and group consultations (n = 3) with older adults and their caregivers. Abstracts that reported description, assessment, or evaluation of strategies for engagement of adult patients, families, or caregivers (i.e., that report on actual experiences of engagement) were included.ResultsThe search generated 15,683 articles, 663 of which were pertinent to healthcare decision making. Theoretical and empirical work identified a range of strategies and levels of engagement of older patients and their families in healthcare decision making. The importance of communication emerged as a key recommendation for meaningful engagement among providers and patients and their caregivers. The principles developed in this study should be implemented with consideration of the context in which care is being provided.ConclusionsWe have developed a framework that promotes the engagement of patients and their caregivers as equal partners in healthcare decision making. Future research should implement and test the framework in various clinical settings.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s40271-016-0168-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Attitudes and factors involved in decision-making around complementary and alternative medicines (CAMs) by older Australians: A qualitative study

“…Similarly to our study a review conducted by Elliot et al [27], described how for older adults engagement in healthcare decision-making is complex. How this occurs varies depending on the characteristics of the person and their situation.…”

Opening up to Open Notes and adding the patient to the team

“…Studies have identified a number of factors that improve patient engagement in healthcare decisions including skills and knowledge, patient/provider relationships built on trust, good communication mechanisms and decreased confusion about choices 9 10. This study of Open Notes, similar to others,7 11 has shown that patients believe having access to notes improves their knowledge and communication with their providers and, notably, that easy access to their notes can improve trust with their providers.…”

Open communication strategies between a triad of ‘experts’ facilitates death in usual place of residence: A realist evaluation

“…Primary care professionals confirmed that patients were often discharged from hospital with 'false hope' of cure because this information had not been conveyed, thus suggesting a dominant curative culture in secondary care. 39 Barriers to ensuring a smooth transition to palliative care in secondary care included the difficulty of 'standing back', professional hierarchies that limited the ability of junior medical and nursing staff to input into decisions on care and poor communication, 50 all of which can be suggested to contribute to the organisational culture of secondary care. Furthermore, it has been found that the diagnosis of dying in secondary care is often made late; this was accredited partly to prognostic uncertainty but also by a curative culture that did not acknowledge death as a possible outcome until it was imminent.…”