Engaging people with dementia in designing playful and creative practices: Co-design or co-creation?

Abstract

Stimulating active, social interactions for people with dementia is an important and timely challenge that merits continuing attention in design research. The idea of using participatory co-design to engage people with dementia is attracting increased interest. In this paper, we draw on our qualitative study that used a playful, participatory arts approach to explore the ways co-design could be implemented in a group of 12 people with dementia and their carers, and developed practical recommendations, in the form of a set of playing cards, for other researchers and caregivers to work in similar ways. The emphasis is on the value of play and playfulness, providing a 'magic circle' (Huizinga, 1955) that fosters the required conditions for a co-creative, co-design space. This aims to encourage social interaction between people with dementia, to stimulate imagination and creativity; and engage even the most the reticent, less confident members. Our observations, however, suggest that the exact notion and nature of co-design within the context of working with people with dementia is unclear. We critically explore whether such participatory creative practices that engage people with dementia can be considered as purely co-design. In conclusion, we argue that such interaction is better described as co-creation and that this definition can still embrace considerable contribution and involvement by people with dementia in a co-design process.

Promoting well-being among people with early-stage dementia and their family carers through community-based group singing: a phenomenological study

“…Responsibilities of day-to-day care, concern around leaving their cared-for alone, and their unpredictable behaviour in social situations can cause family carers to become socially isolated and lonely (Tamplin et al, 2018). The results of our study add to a growing knowledge base for group singing to combat loneliness (Tsekleves et al, 2020).…”

Perspectives of Stakeholders on Technology Use in the Care of Community-Living Older Adults with Dementia: A Systematic Literature Review

“…Another limitation is the fact that in some studies, it was unclear whether perspectives were the actual opinions of persons with dementia or whether (in)formal caregivers thought it might be of importance for persons with dementia. Nowadays, there are research methods and knowledge available about how to ask, observe, or involve persons with dementia themselves instead of asking a proxy [73,74,75]. Since the perspectives of the stakeholders were sometimes different, especially the perspective of informal caregivers, is it important to include persons with dementia themselves to unravel their perspectives on technology use.…”

A qualitative systematic review of experiences of persons with dementia regarding transition to long-term care

“…Future research may, therefore, continue to develop novel and creative means to overcoming challenges to involving a variety of persons with dementia in research (e.g. see Di Lorito et al, 2017;Phillipson & Hammond, 2018;Tsekleves, Bingley, Lujan Escalante, & Gradinar, 2018). The development and adoption of such methods has the potential to respond to the clinical and ethical imperative to listen to the voices of persons with dementia.…”