“…The monthly ELI is thus defined as this average longitude at which SSTs are greater than the threshold temperature for deep convection. We note that the calculation of ELI considers whether the convective threshold is exceeded, and ELI is not weighted by how much the convective threshold is exceeded; nevertheless, ELI explains the global responses of precipitation, temperature, and tropical cyclones at least as well as the Niño3.4 index (Balaguru et al, 2020;Magee & Kiem, 2020;Patricola et al, 2020Patricola et al, , 2022Williams & Patricola, 2018). There is a high correlation between the Niño3.4 index and ELI (R = 0.86 for the December-February (DJF) averages over 1870-2021), which is due to a strong relationship between the two indices for La Niña, neutral ENSO, and weak El Niño events (Figure 1a of Williams & Patricola, 2018); however, the correlation breaks down for strong El Niño events, which ELI is particularly well-suited to capture.…”