Background: Limited English language proficiency in patients undergoing total shoulder arthroplasty (TSA) may make treatment more challenging. Purpose: We sought to investigate the potential association between TSA patients’ use of a language interpreter and 2 outcomes: hospital length of stay (LOS) and discharge disposition. Methods: We conducted a retrospective cohort study comparing LOS and discharge disposition after TSA for patients who required interpreter services and patients who did not at a single institution in an urban setting between 2016 and 2020. Consecutive patients requiring interpreter services who underwent TSA were matched 1:1 to patients who did not require an interpreter by age, body mass index (BMI), sex, and procedure. Multivariate regression models controlling for age, BMI, sex, smoking, opioid use, white or non-white race, procedure, and diagnosis were constructed to determine associations between interpreter use, LOS, and discharge disposition. Results: Forty-one patients were included in each cohort, exceeding the minimum number required per an a priori power analysis. Mean hospital LOS was longer in the interpreter cohort than in the non-interpreter cohort (2.8 ± 2.4 vs 1.8 ± 1.0 days, respectively). Multivariate linear regression demonstrated interpreter use was the strongest predictor of LOS, with the effect estimate indicating an additional 0.88-day LOS per patient. A greater proportion of patients from the interpreter cohort were discharged to an acute/subacute rehabilitation facility than patients from the non-interpreter cohort ( n = 8 [19.5%] vs n = 2 [4.9%], respectively). Patients from the interpreter cohort were 454% more likely to be discharged to acute/subacute rehabilitation facilities. Conclusions: Our retrospective analysis of patients undergoing TSA suggests that the need for interpreter services may be associated with increased LOS and discharge to a facility. More rigorous study is needed to identify the factors that influence these outcomes and to avoid disparities in hospital stay and discharge.