Enhancing Second Language Writing Self-regulation Through Self-assessment and Peer-assessment: A Case of Iranian EFL Learners

Abstract

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the effect of self-assessment and peer-assessment activities on second language (L2) writing self-regulation of Iranian English-as-a-foreign-language (EFL) learners. For this purpose, a sample of forty-six English major students from two intact classes at an Iranian Islamic Azad University were recruited as the participants of the present study. Then, the two classes were randomly assigned to a self-assessment group (N=22) and a peer-assessment group (N=24). The self-assessment group was instructed on the writing assessment criteria in order to self-assess their writing tasks and the peer-assessment group was trained on how to assess the writings of their peers. The treatment carried out for the self-assessment and peer-assessment groups lasted for a period of one university semester. The data was collected through Second Language Writing Self-regulation (SLWS) administered as the pre-test and post-test of the study. The results obtained from the data analysis indicated that both self-assessment and peer-assessment were conducive in enhancing L2 writing self-regulation of the participants. Nevertheless, further analysis of the data indicated that the participants in the peer-assessment group were better than those in the self-assessment group with regard to writing self-regulation, suggesting that peer-assessment activities were more effective than the self-assessment activities in contributing to enhancing writing self-regulation of the EFL learners. The justification of the findings and their implications for L2 writing pedagogy are also discussed.

The Effect of Using Self-Regulation Strategies on Developing Translation Skills and Attitude towards Translation for University Students

“…Peer evaluation used in self-regulation is very efficient to encourage learners while working in translation tasks. This result revealed what Fathi et al (2019) stated as peer-evaluation activities are effective in contributing to improve learning process of the EFL learners. 5.…”

Impact of ChatGPT on ESL students’ academic writing skills: a mixed methods intervention study

“…When operationalized in the form of self-and peer assessment (SA and PA), formative feedback leads to reflection, self-regulation, selfmonitoring, and revision on the parts of students (Lam, 2018). SA and PA can be used to augment learning in large-size writing classrooms often encountered in developing and under-developed countries in the Global South (Fathi & Khodabakhsh, 2019;Mathur & Mahapatra, 2022). However, research on feedback in large writing classes is limited (Rodrigues et al, 2022).…”

Self vs. peer assessment activities in EFL-speaking classes: impacts on students’ self-regulated learning, critical thinking, and problem-solving skills

“…The findings of this study are congruent with the one conducted by Fathi and Khodabakhsh (2020), who found both self-assessment and peer assessment activities helped reduce the writing anxiety of the participants. Similarly, Fathi et al (2019) analyzed the effect of practicing self-assessment and peer assessment activities on the L2 writing selfregulation of Iranian EFL learners. They argued that self-assessment and peer assessment activities made learners concentrate more on the demands of written tasks and found out how to develop their writing competencies and all of their linguistic resources to take more charge of their writing performance.…”