Heteromorphic sex chromosomes have evolved repeatedly among vertebrate lineages despite largely deleterious reductions in gene dose. Understanding how this gene dose problem is overcome is hampered by the lack of genomic information at the base of tetrapods and comparisons across the evolutionary history of vertebrates. To address this problem, we produced a chromosome-level genome assembly for the African Bullfrog (Pyxicephalus adspersus)-an amphibian with heteromorphic ZW sex chromosomes-and discovered that the Bullfrog Z is surprisingly homologous to substantial portions of the human X. Using this new reference genome, we identified ancestral synteny among the sex chromosomes of major vertebrate lineages, showing that non-mammalian sex chromosomes are strongly associated with a single vertebrate ancestral chromosome, while mammals are associated with another that displays increased haploinsufficiency. The sex chromosomes of the African Bullfrog however, share genomic blocks with both humans and non-mammalian vertebrates, connecting the two ancestral chromosome sequences that repeatedly characterize vertebrate sex chromosomes. Our results highlight the consistency of sex-linked sequences despite sex determination system lability and reveal the repeated use of two major genomic sequence blocks during vertebrate sex chromosome evolution.
MAIN TEXTSexual reproduction is the dominant mode of creating offspring among vertebrates 1 , but the fundamental genetic mechanisms that produce two sexes are-in contrast-staggeringly diverse 2,3 . This diversity of genetic sex determination systems is what dictates the formation of sex chromosomes, which differ widely from autosomal chromosomes in their lability, gene content, and structural organization 4,5 . A particular departure from autosomal characteristics is the phenomenon of heteromorphic sex chromosomes which differ in size and gene content. As sex chromosomes evolve, the sex chromosome associated with the heterogametic sex (either Y or W) can experience gene loss, rearrangements, and gains of heterochromatin that change chromosome size and reduce gene dosage on the gametologous X or Z chromosome, respectively 6-12 .At the same time, reductions in gene dosage are largely deleterious [13][14][15][16][17] . Mechanisms of dosage compensation, such as X-inactivation in eutherian mammals 18-20 and X-linked hyperexpression in lizards 21,22 are thought to help solve this problem. However, sex-linked genes are expressed at levels proportional to their copy number in birds, snakes, and liver flukes-all species with ZW sex determination-suggesting a lack of dosage compensation 6,23-27 . The ability to compensate gene dose reductions during sex chromosome evolution in some lineages but tolerate gene dose reductions in others remains poorly understood 24,28 . One hypothesis that addresses this phenomenon is that certain genomic regions are more dose tolerant than others, and shuffling of these syntenic blocks has contributed to the repeated evolution of heteromorphic sex chromoso...