In previous research, fire’s sensory components were disaggregated into separate experimental conditions using a Yule log video to test the hypothesis that domestic fire can induce a relaxation response. The study recorded blood pressure and skin conductance before and after participants watched the 15-minute fire video with and without sound and found a relaxation effect for the audiovisual condition. The current study replicates this with an electric fireplace by measuring pre- and posttest blood pressure (and calculated mean arterial pressure [MAP]) and heart rate (HR) using a randomized crossover design with 101 adults aged 18–60. We duplicated the three original experimental conditions and added an additional condition of fire sounds only. We predicted that the multisensory condition would produce the most relaxation and among those highest in absorption and prosociality. We found a relaxation response for all conditions and more consistent relaxation (systolic, MAP, and HR) and an absorption effect for the multisensory effect; however, the absorption effect was the opposite of our prediction (pre-trial MAP = 92.19 ± 10.95; post-trial = 90.61 ± 10.05, P = .02, df = 97). Our data partially replicate the original study, but the roles of absorption and prosociality need further exploration.