Epidemiology of childhood conduct problems in Brazil: systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

PurposeThis study aimed to review evidence on the prevalence of and risk factors for conduct problems in Brazil.MethodsWe searched electronic databases and contacted Brazilian researchers up to 05/2012. Studies were included in the review if they reported the prevalence of or risk factors for conduct problems, conduct disorder, or oppositional defiant disorder for 100 + Brazilian children aged ≤18 years, systematically sampled in schools or the community. Prevalence rates and sex differences were meta-analysed. Risk factor studies were reviewed one by one.ResultsThe average prevalence of conduct problems in screening questionnaires was 20.8 %, and the average prevalence of conduct disorder/oppositional defiant disorder was 4.1 %. There was systematic variation in the results of screening studies according to methodology: recruitment location, informants, instruments, impairment criterion for case definition, and response rates. Risk factors previously identified in high-income countries were mainly replicated in Brazil, including comorbid mental health problems, educational failure, low religiosity, harsh physical punishment and abuse, parental mental health problems, single parent family, and low socioeconomic status. However, boys did not always have higher risk for conduct problems than girls.ConclusionsStudies using screening questionnaires suggest that Brazilian children have higher rates of conduct problems than children in other countries, but diagnostic studies do not show this difference. Risk factors in Brazil were similar to those in high-income countries, apart from child sex. Future research should investigate developmental patterns of antisocial behaviour, employ a variety of research designs to identify causal risk mechanisms, and examine a broader range of risk factors.

Sex and Age Differences in Psychiatric Disorders among Children and Adolescents: High-Risk Students Study

“…It has been generally accepted that boys usually exhibit a higher rate of conduct disorder. However, some studies have been reported in which boys do not always have a higher risk for conduct disorder than girls 14,15,16. These studies raise questions about the sex difference of conduct disorder.…”

Childhood behaviour problems predict crime and violence in late adolescence: Brazilian and British birth cohort studies

“…Although other questionnaire-based studies in Brazil also document very high levels of child behaviour problems [41, 42], there is debate as to whether this reflects overreporting of symptoms by Brazilian parents [42]. It is possible that specific procedures (for example, reading questionnaires to Brazilian parents with less education) or cultural differences in interpreting questionnaire items causes overestimation of children’s behaviour problems in Brazil.…”

Perinatal and sociodemographic factors at birth predicting conduct problems and violence to age 18 years: comparison of Brazilian and British birth cohorts

“…However, there is unresolved debate about whether Brazilian children actually have such high levels of conduct problems, or whether Brazilian parents tend to overreport problems in short questionnaires (Murray, Anselmi et al. 2013). To help assess this possibility, future studies should include additional measures of child behaviour problems (e.g.…”