The four-stranded i-motif (iM) conformation of cytosine-rich DNA has importance to a wide variety of biochemical systems that range from its use in nanomaterials to a potential role in oncogene regulation. An iM is stabilized by acidic pH that allows hemiprotonated cytidines to form a C•C+ base pair. Fundamental studies to understand how the length of loops connecting the protonated C•C+ pairs affect intramolecular iM physical properties are described in this report. We characterized both the thermal stability and the pKa of intramolecular iMs with differing loop lengths, in both dilute solutions and in solutions containing molecular crowding agents. Our results showed that intramolecular iMs with longer central loops form at higher pH and temperature than iMs with longer outer loops. Our studies also showed that increases in thermal stability of iMs when molecular crowding agents are present are dependent on the loop that is lengthened. However, the increase in pKa for iMs when molecular crowding agents are present is insensitive to loop length. Importantly, we also determined the proton activity of solutions containing high concentrations of molecular crowding agents to ascertain whether the increase in pKa of an iM is due to alteration of this activity in buffered solutions. We determined that crowding agents alone increase the apparent pKa of a number of small molecules as well as iMs, but that increases to iM pKa were greater than that expected from a shift in proton activity.