Epistemological and Moral Conflict Between Religion and Science

Abstract

Debates about religion and educational attainment often assume that members of certain religious groups do not seek out knowledge of science because they are opposed to the use of the scientific method. Using the science module of the 2006 General Social Survey, the analysis indicates that no religious group differs from the nonreligious comparison group in its propensity to seek out scientific knowledge. A more subtle epistemological conflict may arise when scientists make claims that explicitly contradict theological accounts. Findings indicate that Protestants and Catholics differ from the comparison group only on the very few issues where religion and science make competing claims. A third possible source of conflict may not be epistemological, but rather derives from opposition to what is understood as the public moral agenda of scientists. Findings indicate that conservative Protestants are opposed to scientific influence in public affairs due to opposition to the scientists’ moral agenda.

What do people know about climate change ― and how confident are they? On measurements and analyses of science related knowledge

“…Although it may appear more challenging than the measurement of subjective knowledge [e.g., Evans, 2011;McKercher, Prideaux and Pang, 2013], most scholars collect objective knowledge [e.g., Connor and Siegrist, 2010;Tobler, Visschers and Siegrist, 2012].…”

Faith in science in global perspective: Implications for transhumanism

“…They dissent on only a few scientific knowledge claims, like the origins of the earth and humans. Fundamentalists are, however, opposed to the social and moral influence of scientists (Evans, 2011;Evans, 2013). In general, religious Americans support science, but a science dedicated to solving concrete problems, not determining moral values or determining the purpose of humanity.…”

“…H6: Catholics and liberal Protestants will have the same amount of faith in science solving general problems than will the non-religious Finally, research on the U.S. shows that even the most conservative religious people are equally involved with science that is focused on technological manipulation of the physical world (Evans, 2011). Therefore:…”

Individual Religiosity and Orientation towards Science: Reformulating Relationships

“…Research on how the general public views science has relied on survey research to understand individual-level orientation towards science, but too often this topic suffers from overly broad or poorly specified concepts. Although scholars have specified distinctive types of conflict between religion and science (Evans 2011), current research tends to operationalize science as an umbrella concept, often as a component of a dependent variable that assesses perceptions of the relationship between science and religion. Scheitle (2011), for example, examines how numerous dimensions of religiosity shape college students' perceptions of whether science and religion are conflicting, independent, or collaborative.…”