We previously demonstrated that the DNA repair system encoded by the African swine fever virus (ASFV) is both extremely error-prone during the single-nucleotide gap-filling step (catalyzed by ASFV DNA Polymerase X) and extremely error-tolerant during the nick-sealing step (catalyzed by ASFV DNA ligase). On the basis of these findings we have suggested that at least some of the diversity known to exist among ASFV isolates may be a consequence of mutagenic DNA repairwherein damaged nucleotides are replaced with undamaged but incorrect nucleotides by Pol X and the resultant mismatched nicks are sealed by ASFV DNA ligase. Recently, this hypothesis appeared to be discredited by Salas and coworkers [J. Mol. Biol. 2003, 326, 1403-1412 who reported the fidelity of Pol X to be, on average, two orders of magnitude higher than what we previously published. In an effort to address this discrepancy and provide a definitive conclusion about the fidelity of Pol X, herein we examine the fidelity of Pol X-catalyzed single-nucleotide gap-filling in both the steady state and the pre-steady state under a diverse array of assay conditions (varying pH and ionic strength) and within different DNA sequence contexts. These studies corroborate our previously published data (demonstrating the low-fidelity of Pol X to be independent of assay condition/sequence context), do not reproduce the data of Salas et al., and therefore confirm Pol X to be one of the most errorprone polymerases known. These results are discussed in light of ASFV biology and the mutagenic DNA repair hypothesis described above.ASFV 1 causes a disease of varying mortality [depending on the particular isolate (1)] in domestic pigs in Africa, the Iberian Peninsula, and the Caribbean (2). Possessing a large [168-189 kb (3)] double-stranded DNA genome encoding 151 proteins (4), ASFV is one of the most complex viruses known. In its target cells, marcrophages and monocytes (5), ASFV utilizes the host cell nucleus during an early phase of viral DNA synthesis but appears to complete the replication/assembly of its genome in cytoplasmic/perinuclear viral factories (6 -8). Consistent with the latter intracellular location, ASFV encodes its own replicative polymerase in addition to a minimalist DNA repair system consisting of an AP endonuclease (APE), a repair polymerase (Pol X), and an ATP-dependent DNA ligase (4). While this tripartite repair system would appear to have been retained for the purpose of processing spontaneously 2 generated apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites and/or reactive oxygen species (ROS)-induced singlestrand † This work was supported by NIH Grant GM43268. B.J.L. was supported in part by a predoctoral NIH CBIP fellowship (2T32 GM08512).*To whom correspondence should be addressed at the Department of Chemistry [phone: (614) breaks in the viral genome (9), the unique substrate specificities of both Pol X and ASFV DNA ligase have led us to hypothesize that this "repair" system may have subsequently evolved a secondary function, that of viral genome muta...