“…The other involves the modulation of wave instabilities by the accompanied ultralow-frequency (ULF) waves (Helliwell, 1965;McPherron et al, 1968;Sato & Fukunishi, 1981;Sato et al, 1974): (1) the ULF pulsations modulate the background parameters and the resonant particle distributions; (2) the wave instabilities are cyclically turned on and off. Although the ULF pulsations were found to substantially modulate the linear growth rates of whistler-mode emissions in several events (W. Li et al, 2011;Manninen et al, 2010), there are still the quasiperiodic whistler-mode emissions occurring without the observable ULF pulsations (Boardsen et al, 2014;Kitamura et al, 1969;Němec et al, 2014;Sato et al, 1974;Titova et al, 2015;Tsurutani & Smith, 1974) or with the ULF pulsations of the essentially different periods (Němec et al, 2015). In contrast, there is evidence both for and against the latter scenario.…”