Equity for health delivery: Opportunity costs and benefits among Community Health Workers in Rwanda

Abstract

Community Health Workers (CHWs) play a vital role delivering health services to vulnerable populations in low resource settings. In Rwanda, CHWs provide village-level care focused on maternal/child health, control of infectious diseases, and health education, but do not receive salaries for these services. CHWs make up the largest single group involved in health delivery in the country; however, limited information is available regarding the socioeconomic circumstances and satisfaction levels of this workforce. Such information can support governments aiming to control infectious diseases and alleviate poverty through enhanced healthcare delivery. The objectives of this study were to (1) evaluate CHW opportunity costs, (2) identify drivers for CHW motivation, job satisfaction and care provision, and (3) report CHW ideas for improving retention and service delivery. In this mixed-methods study, our team conducted in-depth interviews with 145 CHWs from three districts (Kirehe, Kayonza, Burera) to collect information on household economics and experiences in delivering healthcare. Across the three districts, CHWs contributed approximately four hours of volunteer work per day (range: 0-12 hrs/day), which translated to 127 684 RWF per year (range: 2 359-2 247 807 RWF/yr) in lost personal income. CHW out-of-pocket expenditures (e.g. patient transportation) were estimated at 36 228 RWF per year (range: 3 600-364 800 RWF/yr). Participants identified many benefits to being CHWs, including free healthcare training, improved social status, and the satisfaction of helping others. They also identified challenges, such as aging equipment, discrepancies in financial reimbursements, poverty, and lack of formal workspaces or working hours. Lastly, CHWs provided perspectives on reasonable and feasible improvements to village-level health programming that could improve conditions and equity for those providing and using the CHW system.

Starting at the community: Treatment seeking pathways of children with suspected severe malaria in Uganda

“…Even though CHWs are often community members without formal work engagements, taking care of the community’s sick children comes with opportunity costs for taking care of their own households (child care, farming etc.). 35 36 To compensate CHWs for their investments, recommendations to formalize iCCM programmes and pay CHWs have been made in the past and emphasized again more recently. 37 38 In Uganda, attempts into this direction have been made; however, so far with little success.…”

The Impact of Covid-19 on Malaria Services in Three High Endemic Districts in Rwanda – A Mixed-Method Study

“…This reiterates the importance of bringing care closer to the community and exempli es the value of the CHWs in ensuring continuous delivery of essential health services especially during pandemics that may require lockdown. However, CHWs are already overburdened with many other health-related activities (32). As more people may continue to use community services, the malaria program should ensure that the program of home-based management of malaria is well-equipped and CHWs are not overburdened by an increase in a number of patients.…”

Community health workers at the dawn of a new era: 1. Introduction: tensions confronting large-scale CHW programmes

“…There are often opportunity costs associated with CHW work: time spent on CHW duties is time unavailable for other income-generating activities. There are also many examples of CHWs spending their own money to perform their role without being compensated, such as transportation expenses to help a patient obtain healthcare at a facility or needed medication [ 44 ].…”