Errors in medicine: punishment versus learning medical adverse events revisited – expanding the frame

Abstract

Purpose of reviewDespite healthcare workers’ best intentions, some patients will suffer harm and even death during their journey through the healthcare system. This represents a major challenge, and many solutions have been proposed during the last decades. How to reduce risk and use adverse events for improvement?Recent findingsThe concept of safety culture must be acknowledged and understood for moving from blame to learning. Procedural protocols and reports are only parts of the solution, and this overview paints a broader picture, referring to recent research on the nature of adverse events. The potential harm from advice based on faulty evidence represents a serious risk.SummaryFocus must shift from an individual perspective to the system, promoting learning rather than punishment and disciplinary sanctions, and the recent opioid epidemic is an example of bad guidelines.

Fostering path to a just culture in healthcare organizations: Influential factors and challenges

“…Despite healthcare professionals' unwavering dedication to providing optimal care, there are occasions when patients may experience harm or, tragically, loss of life within the healthcare system. Recent research highlights the importance of acknowledging and comprehending the concept of safety culture as a pivotal step in transitioning from a culture of blame to one that emphasizes learning (Brattebø & Flaatten, 2023).…”