“…An older date of 11.23 ± 226 cal 14 C ka BP has been suggested for this tephra based on evidence from a site in Poland(Ott et al 2016), but this is an outlier compared with the majority of dates available(Kearney et al 2018). For completeness, however, both age estimates are employed in separate age models presented in Appendix F. older tephra in the Kingshouse 2 sequence, assigned to the Abernethy Tephra (AT), is more equivocal, because of its close chemical similarity with the Vedde Ash (VA), which dates to ~12.1 ka BP (Bronk Ramsey et al, 2015): it has been argued that small traces of glass shards that have been assigned to the AT could be reworked VA instead (seeTimms et al, 2019). This is unlikely in this case, however, because the VA is usually the most prominent peak in glass shard concentrations in Lateglacial deposits in sites in the Scottish Highlands, and if present in the Kingshouse 2 basin, it should be more strongly represented.…”