Estimates of Soil Ingestion in a Population of Chinese Children

Abstract

Background:China’s soil pollution poses serious health risks. However, data regarding the soil ingestion rate (SIR) of the Chinese population, which is critical to assessing associated health risks, are lacking.Objectives:We estimated soil ingestion of 177 Chinese children from Guangdong, Hubei, and Gansu Provinces.Methods:We conducted this investigation by employing a tracer mass-balance method. We collected a duplicate of all food consumed and all feces and urine excreted on 1 d (n=153) and over 3 consecutive d (n=24), as well as soil samples from play areas and drinking-water samples. We analyzed concentrations of the tracer elements Al, Ba, Ce, Mn, Sc, Ti, V, and Y in these samples using ICP-AES and ICP-MS and estimated the SIR for each subject.Results:The estimated SIR data based on each tracer element were characterized by a skewed distribution, as well as higher inter-tracer and inter-subject variation, with several outliers. After removing the outliers, daily SIR median (range) values in milligrams per day were Al, 27.8 (−42.0 to 257.3); Ba, 36.5 (−230.3 to 412.7); Ce, 35.3 (−21.2 to 225.8); Mn, 146.6 (−1259.4 to 1827.7); Sc, 54.8 (−4.5 to 292.0); Ti, 36.7 (−233.7 to 687.0); V, 92.1 (10.4 to 308.0); and Y, 59.1 (−18.4 to 283.0). Daily SIR median/95th percentile (range) values based on the best tracer method (BTM) were 51.7/216.6 (−9.5 to 297.6) mg/d.Conclusions:Based on the BTM, recommended SIR values for the general population of Chinese children (2.5 to 12 years old) are 52mg/d for the central tendency and 217mg/d for the upper percentile. We did not differentiate between outside soil and indoor dust. Considering the lower concentration of tracer elements in indoor dust than outside soil, actual soil and dust ingestion rates could be higher. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP930

Child soil ingestion in rural Ghana – frequency, caregiver perceptions, relationship with household floor material and associations with child diarrhoea

“…Based on a review of several studies with varying techniques, the EPA has recommended soil ingestion factors of approximately 20–40 mg/day for various age groups in children under 6 years in the United States, with a factor of 1000 mg/day recommended for children practicing soil‐pica and 50 000 mg/day recommended for children practicing geophagy . These factors are similar to soil ingestion factors that were measured in recent studies using biomarkers in Asia, including in Taiwan where average soil ingestion rates for children under 3 years old were estimated as 9.6 mg/day using Si as a tracer and 923 mg/day using Ti as a tracer and in China where average soil ingestion rates were 51.7 mg/day for children .…”

Soil ingestion among young children in rural Bangladesh

“…This study contributes to the sparse literature on soil ingestion among children in lower-income countries. Of the three published estimates of soil ingestion in lower-income countries, our estimates are 3-5 times higher than those for children in mainland China [47], within the range of estimates for institutionalized children in Jamaica [42], and substantially less than estimates for children in Zimbabwe [21] ( Table 2). The authors of the study in Zimbabwe rubbed soil on a children's hands to estimate that soil adhesion on heavily soiled hands was 250 wet mg/hand [21] whereas we rinsed children's hands following normal daily activities and estimated a mean soil adhesion of 11.5 dry mg/hand.…”

Quantificational exposure, sources, and health risks posed by heavy metals in indoor and outdoor household dust in a typical smelting area in China

“…The time spent in outdoor and indoor was obtained through the questionnaire‐based survey and is listed in Table S2. The other exposure parameters, such as the IngR of the dust, were obtained from the literatures 10,11,39,42 and are listed in Table S2.…”