Proteins require an optimal balance of conformational flexibility and stability in their native environment to ensure their biological functions. A striking example is spidroins, spider silk proteins, which are stored at extremely high concentrations in soluble form, yet undergo amyloid‐like aggregation during spinning. Here, we elucidate the stability of the highly soluble N‐terminal domain (NT) of major ampullate spidroin 1 in the
Escherichia coli
cytosol as well as in inclusion bodies containing fibrillar aggregates. Surprisingly, we find that NT, despite being largely composed of amyloidogenic sequences, showed no signs of concentration‐dependent aggregation. Using a novel intracellular hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) approach, we reveal that NT adopts a tight fold in the
E. coli
cytosol and in this manner conceals its aggregation‐prone regions by maintaining a tight fold under crowded conditions. Fusion of NT to the unstructured amyloid‐forming Aβ
40
peptide, on the other hand, results in the formation of fibrillar aggregates. However, HDX‐MS indicates that the NT domain is only partially incorporated into these aggregates
in vivo
. We conclude that NT is able to control its aggregation to remain functional under the extreme conditions in the spider silk gland.